Lipstick Bandits: A Gentleman’s Choice

The Lipstick Bandits are letting the men pick for this round-up of lipsticks. What would the man (boyfriend / husband / brother / father / best friend) in your life choose?

This challenge is a pretty exciting one because boys mixed with makeup are just bound to be hilarious. And I was right! I warned Mr. Geeks about this Lipstick Bandits topic for months in advance and he was totally on board. That is, until I started putting on lipstick for him. Each time I put on a new shade, he let out a huge sigh, and then asked me to cover my eyes, because he said I was watching him think. :D

Arianne: What are you looking for in a lipstick?
Mr. Geeks: Something that doesn’t look like you’re wearing lipstick, and doesn’t look clowny. Something that evens out your lips and just adds a bit more contrast. Something that isn’t shiny. I hate shiny.

Five lipsticks later he was convinced that I was putting on the same lipstick for comparison. At one point I was wearing Laura Mercier Dulce de Leche on one half, and MAC Lovelorn on the other, and he exclaims, “they look the same!!!”

Mr. Geeks: Wait wait wait… I need to know the context for the lipstick I’m picking. Is it for everyday, or is it for a wedding? I wouldn’t pick the same for both.
Arianne: Hmm… okay. Pick the colour that you’d want me to wear on a date.
Mr. Geeks: In that case, I don’t mind it shiny.

Ten lipsticks later, he was eeny-meeny-miney-moe-ing between two choices, and we finally have a winner:

Lipstick Bandits His Pick Chanel Jersey Rose Lipstick 4
Mr. Geeks’ Pick: Chanel Rouge Coco in Jersey Rose

Chanel Rouge Coco in Jersey Rose ($37) is a light rosy pink with a yellow undertone. I don’t know if you can see in the photo how much I’ve used Jersey Rose, but I am telling you that this is probably the first lipstick that I’ll ever finish. It’s a great everyday lipstick, and it’s also a great date night shade.

Lipstick Bandits His Pick Chanel Jersey Rose Lipstick 2
Chanel Rouge Coco in Jersey Rose Swatch

Was I surprised at Mr. Geeks’ pick? Not at all. If he had his way, I’d wear no lipstick at all actually. To him, he likes makeup that emphasizes the eyes, so subtle smudging around the lashes is enough to get a “You look nice!” comment from him.

Lipstick Bandits His Pick Chanel Jersey Rose Lipstick 1
Wearing Chanel Rouge Coco in Jersey Rose

Lipstick Bandits His Pick Chanel Jersey Rose Lipstick 3

Other Products Used

shu uemura Hard Formula in 02 Seal Brown
Benefit Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow in Bikini-tini
MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil in Industry
YSL Dessin Du Regard Waterproof Eye Pencil in 1 Black Ink
Givenchy Noir Couture Waterproof Mascara

Tarte Amazonian Clay Blush in Blissful (review)
MAC Blush in Supercontinental (LE)
Chanel Ombre Contraste in Notorious (review / LE)

Now it’s time to check out the rest of the Mr. Lipstick Bandit picks! :)

This entry was posted in Chanel, Looks, Makeup, Reviews, Swatches and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Pingback: MOSTLY SUNNY | Lipstick Bandits Bring the Boys Out!

  • Pingback: Tom Ford Nude Vanille Lipstick-Lipstick Bandits Beauty Reflections

  • http://www.bellachique.be/ Teri

    It sounds like your man had a better idea of what he wanted in a lipstick. At least he asked for some background information, haha. I think he chose well, it’s subtle but it adds something pretty to your look, looks like he has great taste!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      He knows *exactly* what he wants. I knew this. Anything that steers away from the natural lip colour and he thinks it’s too fake.

  • Mariella (Musing on Beauty)

    Very nice!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks!

  • http://mostlysunnyblog.com/ Sunny @Mostly Sunny

    Hahaha I am beginning to think guys are a bit colorblind, but Mr. Geeks ended up picking SUCH A LOVELY SHADE for you! Now I need to swatch this thing, dang it ;)

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Sunny! :) I think they just don’t see nuances of colours…

  • Toya

    Diggin’ the whole look Arianne! That lipstick is perfect, and I’m really loving the softly smudged eyes too. Mr. Geeks did well! :P

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Toya! :) I like this look, too. The lipstick is my favourite!

  • Pingback: Lipstick Bandits: His Choice | ChloeAsh – A Beauty Blog

  • Rema Gouyez-Benallal

    omg cutest idea for a post ever. LOVE it! And his answers are amazing.

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      So good, right? He cracks me up.

  • http://macyxmakeup.blogspot.com/ Macy

    This is so pretty on you! Love it!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Macy!

  • Lily

    You actually got a lot of input from Mr Geeks. I haven’t swatched this one before, but it looks amazing with your smokey eyes! I have to check it out for sure

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      The guy knows what he wants! I’d love to know what you think of the lipstick when you check it out. :)

  • Ria Harris

    I love the concept of this post. I’ve always heard men prefer a natual looking lip but have never took much notice haha.

    Jazzie x

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Hi Jazzie! I don’t care either. If I’m not going on a dinner date with him, it’s no holds barred when I pick my lip colour. :)

  • http://thenotice.net Rae // theNotice

    Aww, what a pretty pink! My guy is much the same when it comes to makeup — LOVES a smudgy eye; barely notices a lip colour :P

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      YES! Sometimes I’d just smudge a tiny bit of grey liner: “You look nice. Did you do something different? Where you going?” Hahaha.

  • messywands

    We use the same eyebrow pencil :D Mr. Geekz was *really* specific, so fun! and i feel like all our guys are into eyes. I wonder if it’s because makeup in media emphasizes that part of the face the most?

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Hahaha he’s so specific. Even side by side comparisons… “I don’t like that one. Too shiny.” xD He says he looks at my eyes, not my lips, so if he likes my eye makeup he doesn’t really notice the rest of the face.

  • Lorraine

    Love his pick! and that he asked for what occasion you are wearing to. Smart guy! like this lipstick, definitely a keeper!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      He’s a smart one. He wanted to give the correct answer. :D

  • http://eyeheartit.blogspot.com Larie

    LOL Mr. Geeks cracks me up. So specific! Too cute. You look GOOD, Arianne.

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thank you Larie-pie! :D

  • TracyBeautyReflections

    Hahaha I love this-Mr. Geeks actually sounds like Terry when he was younger haha!
    I love Jersey Rose on you! It’s so pretty on you-so fresh!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Ahahhaaha they are all the same aren’t they???

  • http://prettypandmakeup.blogspot.com/ Margo @ PrettyPandaMakeup

    he did a great job!!! love it!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Margo! I’ll let him know. ;)

  • gigidob

    Oooh I loved Jersey Rose. One of the few lipsticks I’ve ever finished. Good choice Mr. Geeks! :)

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Very nice! What other lipsticks have you finished gigidob?

  • http://rocaille-writes.blogspot.com/ Rocaille

    I think it’s the perfect neutral pink for you, Arianne, I love it! Mr Geekz definitely has very good taste :)

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Monika! But I don’t know about good taste… he doesn’t like red lipstick. :P

  • http://beautyreductionista.blogspot.ca/ Liz

    Context?? LOLOL He’s adorable!

    I love how you did the eyes. The entire look is perfection!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      He’s a “big picture” kinda guy. :D

  • http://www.mywomenstuff.com/ Paris B

    Haha love the whole back story Arianne! This looks lovely on you. Such a gentle colour and perfect with smokey eyes!

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Paris. :)

  • http://miaka-mylife.blogspot.com/ Ruby Chua

    You got me laughing at the conversation with Mr Geek choosing the lipstick, Arianne! He made a good choice, this lipstick shade looks gorgeous on you.

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Hahaha glad you got a kick out of it, Ruby!

  • Pingback: What Men Want (Tom Ford Cherry Lush): a Lipstick Bandits Post | My Funny Valentine

  • Jenny W

    Mr Geekz is hilarious! He’s picked well though- Jersey Rose is beautiful on you. Very date appropriate too.

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Jenny. He’s so pleased with himself, that one. :P

  • http://aucupariabrumalis.wordpress.com/ Claire

    love the story! I actually like the whole makeup look, everything looks so perfect on you xxx

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Claire! :) How was your day?

  • lenita

    This is a fun and interesting theme. This shade is nice on you.

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thanks Lenita!

  • JessicaGettingCheeky

    Arianne, I love the interview format of your post! Though Mr. Geeks seems quite picky where your lipstick is concerned he made an excellent selection. It looks perfectly “no makeup” makeup. You are, of course, effortlessly beautiful as always dear!

    ♥ Jessica

    • http://www.glittergeek.ca/ Arianne

      Thank you so much Jessica. :) I think Mr. Geeks enjoys getting a bit of the spotlight on the blog. ;)

  • http://kissandmakeupsbeautyblog.com/ Kiss & Make-up

    Awesome post, fun to read :-) And what a great choice, this shade looks lovely on you!

  • BooBooNinja

    I’m getting a kick out of this Lipstick Bandits challenge. :)

  • Rachel

    Love it! I’m going to have to add you to the list of blogs i read!

  • http://www.glambunctious.com/ Kristen / Glambunctious

    Mr. Geeks has great taste in lip products! I love this color on you! I really enjoyed hearing his analysis whilst coming to this decision. My dude is quite analytical and would totally have to do a lot of thinking and reasoning (Microsoft Excel might need to be involved) before he cast his vote! Great topic!

  • Pingback: Link Love Vol. 10 | Softly Sometimes